THE SHITTY LEADERSHIP SERIES - FREE SHIT TO READ

The Loyalty Tax: When Good Employees Pay the Price for Sticking Around 

You say you value loyalty, but let’s be honest—you’re punishing it.

Your longest-serving employees? They’re doing the work of three people, training new hires, and building the systems that keep your business running. Meanwhile, the fresh recruits are walking in with higher salaries, better perks, and half the responsibility—all because they had the audacity to job-hop while your best people stayed and kept your company afloat.

And what do your loyal employees get for their years of dedication?  

❌ No real raise—just the standard cost-of-living bump that barely covers inflation.  

❌ More work—because they “know the system best.”  

❌ Zero financial recognition—but hey, here''s a t-shirt and a gift card!  

This isn’t employee retention—it’s employee exploitation.  

If your team has to leave to get paid what they’re worth, you don’t have a retention problem—you have a shitty leadership problem. Fix it before your real MVPs walk out the door and take your company’s success with them.

Look, not every company is rolling in cash, and we get it—you have to be smart, frugal, and bring on key talent when needed. That’s just good business. But here’s the thing—if you don’t have a clear financial compensation structure that your key employees understand, or if you avoid having real conversations about their future earning potential, don’t be surprised when they start feeling undervalued.  

No one expects overnight raises and endless bonuses (okay, some do, but let’s be real). What your employees do expect is transparency. If you can’t afford big raises right now, then at least acknowledge their hard work, and be upfront about what’s possible down the road.  

Instead of staying silent and hoping they’ll just be grateful, try this:  

✅ Tell them where they stand. What’s the plan for their growth? What benchmarks do they need to hit to move up financially?   

✅ Be real about timing. If a raise isn't in the cards today, when will it be? How can they get there?  

✅ Acknowledge their contributions. If someone is doing the work of three people, don’t just say “we appreciate you”—show them with flexibility, recognition, or other meaningful incentives.  

Your best people don’t just work for you—they choose to stay. And if you don’t give them a reason to believe their loyalty will pay off, they’ll make another choice—to work somewhere else.  

Being a CEO isn’t just about managing numbers—it’s about leading people. And that starts with having the conversations that matter.  Honest conversations go along way, and then you give the empowerment back to your staff now armed with their knowledge of how they wish to proceed.